Debt Management Vs. Debt Settlement: What’s The Difference?

If you’re struggling to get out of debt, you might be considering debt management vs. debt settlement as a solution. Although these two options sound similar, they offer distinct pathways and cater to different financial situations.

While both debt management and debt settlement can provide relief, they operate in different ways and have varying implications for your credit score, cost, and debt repayment timeline. This article aims to clarify the differences between the two and help you decide which option may be best for you.

What is Debt Management?

Debt management refers to a structured program offered by credit counseling agencies to help individuals repay unsecured debts, primarily credit card balances, through a debt management plan (DMP). Unlike debt settlement, debt management doesn’t involve negotiating with creditors to reduce the debt amount owed. Instead, it consolidates multiple credit card debts into one with a single monthly payment at a reduced interest rate.

Debt management plans typically last between three to five years. During this period, you are required to stop using your credit cards and refrain from opening new lines of credit. Some plans may also necessitate closing existing credit card accounts.

One of the primary advantages of debt management is that it doesn’t negatively impact your credit score. Working with a reputable, nonprofit credit counseling agency ensures that you receive expert guidance and support throughout the process.

When to Consider Debt Management

• You Have Significant Credit Card Debt: Debt management plans are particularly beneficial if your main source of debt is credit card balances. By consolidating these debts into one manageable payment, you can simplify your finances and potentially save money on interest.
• You Can’t Qualify for Other Debt Payoff Options: If you have a lower credit score, options like balance transfer cards may not be accessible. Debt management plans don’t require a minimum credit score, making them an attractive option for those who may not qualify for other forms of debt relief.
• You Can Afford the Fees: While debt management plans are generally affordable, they may involve setup and monthly maintenance fees ranging from $20 to $75. Be sure to consider whether you can handle these additional costs.
• You’re Ready to Commit to a Long-Term Plan: Debt management is not a quick fix. It requires discipline and commitment to making regular payments over a few years. This commitment can help instill financial discipline and prevent future debt accumulation.
• You Want to Avoid Further Debt Accumulation: By closing your credit cards and focusing on a debt management plan, you reduce the temptation to incur additional debt, thereby promoting healthier financial habits.

What is Debt Settlement?

Debt settlement is a process in which you negotiate with creditors to settle a lower amount than the debts you owe. Typically facilitated by a for-profit debt settlement company, this approach involves convincing creditors to accept a reduced payment as a lump sum, thereby resolving the debt.

The process often starts with the debt settlement company advising you to stop making payments on your debts and instead funnel money into an escrow account. As your debt becomes delinquent, the company negotiates with creditors, hoping they will accept a smaller amount rather than risk getting nothing.

Debt settlement companies usually charge a fee of 15% to 25% of the amount owed for each successful settlement. Although debt settlement can significantly reduce your debt, it comes with considerable risks, including potential damage to your credit score and no guarantee that creditors will accept the settlement offer.

When to Consider Debt Settlement

• You Have a Mix of Unsecured Debt: Debt settlement can be an option for those with various unsecured debts, such as credit card balances, medical bills, or personal loans. However, it doesn’t apply to secured debts like auto loans or mortgages.
• You Can’t Repay the Full Amount: If you’re certain that you cannot repay your debts in full, debt settlement might offer a way out. However, it’s crucial to explore other debt relief options before committing to this path.
• You’re Prepared for Credit Score Impacts: Debt settlement can negatively impact your credit score due to missed payments and reduced debt settlements. If you’re willing to accept this consequence for the sake of financial relief, it might be worth considering.
• You’re Comfortable with Uncertainty: The debt settlement process can be lengthy, often taking several years, and there’s no guarantee that creditors will accept the offer. Be prepared for potential setbacks and delays.

Debt Management Vs. Debt Settlement: Key Differences

• Impact on Credit Score

Debt management does not negatively impact your credit score, as it involves a structured repayment plan without any missed payments. In contrast, debt settlement can harm your credit score due to the missed payments required to initiate negotiations and the potential negative reporting by creditors.

• Cost

Debt management plans involve setup and monthly fees ranging from $20 to $75. On the other hand, debt settlement companies charge a fee of 15% to 25% of the total debt amount settled. Additional fees may also apply.

• Timeline

Debt management plans typically last three to five years, offering a structured approach to debt repayment. Debt settlement timelines vary and can extend up to four years, depending on the negotiations and creditor cooperation.

Other Ways to Achieve Debt Relief

While debt management and debt settlement are viable options for debt relief, they are not the only methods available. Consider these additional options before making a decision:

• DIY Debt Payoff

If your debt load is manageable, consider tackling it independently through strategies like the avalanche method or the snowball method. The avalanche method prioritizes paying off debts with the highest interest rates first, while the snowball method focuses on settling the smallest debts to build momentum.

• Debt Consolidation

Debt consolidation involves combining multiple debts into one, ideally at a lower interest rate. This can be achieved through balance-transfer cards or debt consolidation loans. Balance-transfer cards offer promotional 0% interest rates, while debt consolidation loans provide a fixed rate over a set period, typically two to seven years.

• Bankruptcy

If your debt exceeds 40% of your income and you’re unable to repay it within five years, bankruptcy might be an option. This legal process can help discharge unsecured debts or establish a repayment plan with more favorable terms. However, bankruptcy can have long-lasting effects on your credit score and financial standing, so consult a bankruptcy attorney before proceeding.

A Positive Path Forward with Value Capital Funding

We help small business clients struggling with excessive MCA debt find relief through personalized debt restructuring solutions. Our approach involves immediate action without the need for new loans, collateral, or minimum FICO scores. With a commitment to transparency and a warm client experience, we provide the guidance needed to regain financial stability.

For qualified businesses, we also offer a one-stop-shop platform to secure affordable capital through FDIC bank and credit union term loans and lines of credit. By understanding your unique circumstances, we tailor solutions that align with your goals and aspirations.

Contact us today to explore your options and take the first step toward a brighter financial future.